Fiat Ducato vs Peugeot Boxer – Kumpi auto on parempi valinta?

When it comes to the world of commercial vans, the Fiat Ducato and the Peugeot Boxer stand out as two of the most popular choices among business owners and fleet managers alike. Both vehicles share a common platform, yet they offer distinct characteristics that can make one more suitable than the other depending on specific needs. In this article, we’ll delve into the technical specifications, innovative features, and performance aspects of both models to see how they stack up against each other.

Body and Dimensions: Capacity Meets Versatility

Both the Fiat Ducato and the Peugeot Boxer are primarily designed as cargo vans, offering ample space for transporting goods. The Ducato boasts various lengths ranging from 5,413 mm to 6,678 mm and offers multiple height options, making it highly customizable for different business needs. The maximum width is 2,100 mm, providing a significant amount of cargo space.

On the other hand, the Boxer measures between 4,963 mm and 6,363 mm in length, ensuring it remains compact while still spacious enough for most commercial applications. With a maximum height of 2,760 mm and a width of 2,050 mm, it competes closely with the Ducato while retaining its own unique advantages in accessibility and maneuverability.

Engine Options: Powering Your Business

The Ducato is available with several powertrains, including diesel and electric options. The diesel engines range from 120 HP to a robust 270 HP, allowing for significant versatility in performance. The Ducato has a wide torque range of 320 Nm to 450 Nm, catering to different operational demands. Its fuel consumption averages between 7.2 to 9.3 L/100km, depending on the variant.

In contrast, the Boxer also offers a selection of diesel engines, ranging from 120 HP to 165 HP, although it does not quite reach the Ducato's upper limits. The torque figures range from 260 Nm to 370 Nm, which are adequate for lighter duty cycles. The Boxer has a slightly higher fuel consumption rate, averaging around 7.9 to 8.9 L/100km.

Transmission and Drive System: Smooth Operations

Both models provide front-wheel drive and a choice of manual or automatic transmission, ensuring that drivers can select a setup they are comfortable with. The Ducato features hydraulic systems such as a manual gearbox or an automatic gearbox, capable of providing a smooth driving experience. The inclusion of a reduction gearbox allows for more precise control in challenging driving conditions.

The Boxer, while offering a manual gearbox and a reduction gearbox, lacks the diversity in automatic options seen in the Ducato. This could potentially influence buyer preferences depending on the expected driving conditions and personal preferences for driving dynamics.

Innovative Features: Technology Meets Functionality

The Fiat Ducato sets itself apart by including advanced technology such as a state-of-the-art infotainment system that adapts to a variety of smartphone applications—ideal for business connectivity. Furthermore, the Ducato boasts impressive safety features including lane assist, adaptive cruise control, and blind-spot monitoring, making it one of the safest options on the market.

Meanwhile, the Peugeot Boxer includes a less extensive suite of tech offerings. However, it provides reliable features that cater to the practicalities of transportation, such as parking assistance systems and various driving aids. For businesses seeking simplicity and ease-of-use without excessive tech, the Boxer remains an appealing option.

Payload and Efficiency: The Bottom Line

Payload capacity is critical for commercial vehicles, and both models deliver. The Ducato supports a payload ranging up to 2,020 kg, while the Boxer offers generous payload figures up to 1,835 kg. Depending on the specific model and configuration chosen, either vehicle can accommodate heavy loads effectively.

In terms of CO2 emissions, the Ducato has CO2 efficiency classes ranging from E to A, with emissions reaching as low as 190 g/km in certain models. The Boxer ranges from class A to G, indicating that while both vans are relatively efficient, the Ducato might edge out in terms of environmentally friendly options.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

Ultimately, the choice between the Fiat Ducato and the Peugeot Boxer comes down to individual needs. The Ducato excels with its powerful engine options, advanced technology, and a broader range of possible configurations. The Boxer, however, offers a dependable and straightforward alternative that might be particularly appealing for those needing a versatile workhorse without excessive bells and whistles.

Your decision will depend largely on your business requirements—whether it’s payload capacity, engine performance, technological integration, or just basic versatility. Test-driving both options is highly recommended to determine which van feels best suited for your operational needs.